← All reports

A historian's proposal for a third Scottish independence referendum is a Unionist trick designed to prevent Scottish independence.

PoliticsScottish IndependenceUnionist InfluenceOct 29, 2026score 0.352 posts · 0 replies across 1 instances
The thread discusses a media report criticizing a historian's proposal for a third Scottish independence referendum, suggesting it is a Unionist trick. The posts highlight the historian's association with a British Nationalist think tank and question the credibility of the proposal.

Claims

A historian's proposal for a third Scottish independence referendum is a Unionist trick designed to prevent Scottish independence.
Parent: Scottish IndependenceEntity: Historian's proposal for a third independence referendumImpact: negativeDate: Oct 29, 2026Target: The credibility of the historian's proposal as a genuine attempt to advance Scottish independence.

Source posts

@[email protected]
Media Watch: Historian's cunning plan for a “third” indy referendum is a Unionist trick A Unionist historian has come up with a new idea to prevent Scottish independence - the idea of a two-stage independence referendum. The Herald presented the column by Professor Colin Kidd as coming from “one of Scotland’s leading historians” - but they failed to mention that Kidd sits on the board of dark-money-funded, aggressively British Nationalist think tank “These Islands”. https://www.believeinscotland.org/media_watch_historians_cunning_plan_for_a_third_indy_referendum_is_a_unionist_trick?utm_campaign=unionist_trick_newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_source=believeinscotland
2 boosts · 3 favs · 1 replies · Oct 29, 2026
@[email protected]
Media Watch: Historian's cunning plan for a “third” indy referendum is a Unionist trick - Believe in Scotland https://www.believeinscotland.org/media_watch_historians_cunning_plan_for_a_third_indy_referendum_is_a_unionist_trick
1 boosts · 1 favs · 0 replies · Oct 29, 2026