Bavarian Court Declares Dobrindt's Internal Border Controls Illegal Over Unsubstantiated Migrant Threats

Governance & PoliticsApr 19, 2026score 1.384 posts · 10 replies across 4 instances

The Bavarian Administrative Court ruled that internal border controls implemented by Bavarian Minister Dobrindt are illegal because the alleged threats from migrants were not adequately substantiated. This ruling forms the core case study in a discussion about border law adherence.

Arguments are sharply divided on the utility of legal action. Some users, like @[email protected], insist more lawsuits are necessary to force the rule of law and criticize politicians for setting bad examples. Conversely, others, such as @[email protected], dismiss individual lawsuits as futile, arguing the general public bears the financial costs, making political structural change the only real target.

The consensus points to a fundamental breakdown in legal adherence by politicians. While the immediate focus is the Bavarian ruling, the discussion expands to broader allegations of systemic rights violations concerning migration across the Mediterranean and EU borders. The main fault line exists between punitive legal action against officials versus systemic political change.

Key points

SUPPORT

Bavarian border controls were ruled illegal by the Bavarian Administrative Court due to insufficient proof of migrant threats.

Consensus affirms the ruling itself, citing @[email protected]'s report.

OPPOSE

Initiating individual lawsuits against state authorities is a questionable strategy.

@[email protected] claims the public pays the costs, and suing individuals only punishes the public.

SUPPORT

A collective legal action lawsuit targeting quantifiable damages is an alternative proposal.

@[email protected] suggests a WAMCA lawsuit in the Netherlands covering petrol costs and lost travel time.

SUPPORT

Politicians must follow the law, making their overstepping hypocritical.

@[email protected] states that politicians cannot demand law-abiding behavior from citizens while breaking the law themselves.

SUPPORT

The fundamental right to freedom must apply universally, regardless of origin or status.

@[email protected] cites Article 2 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

SUPPORT

The economic damage from illegal controls severely impacts professional drivers and travelers.

@[email protected] details financial damages, like missing appointments or exceeding driving time limits.

Source posts

@[email protected]

Migreurop
Les États du Maghreb et de l’Union européenne coupables de violations systématiques du droit international et de crimes contre l’humanité
https://mcinformactions.net/les-etats-du-maghreb-et-de-l-union-europeenne-coupables-de-violations
#migrants #immigration #droitInternational #UE #Maghreb #TPP

3 boosts · 0 favs · 0 replies · Apr 9, 2026

#tpp#maghreb#ue#droitinternational#immigration#migrants

@[email protected]

Hello les #nazillon #nazillonounets 🙂 
On vous informe que nous, les #gauchistes , continuons d'aider les #migrants  à finir leurs voyages, vers l' #Angleterre  #brexit et donc hors #Europe , si telle est leur volonté.

Pas qu'il-elle-s sont malvenus ici - refugees welcome 🙂 - mais si telle est leur volonté alors elle doit être exécutée 🙂 

https://www.lemonde.fr/international/article/2026/01/01/immigration-plus-de-41-000-personnes-ont-traverse-la-manche-pour-rejoindre-le-royaume-uni-en-2025-au-plus-haut-depuis-2022_6660218_3210.html

1 boosts · 0 favs · 0 replies · Apr 7, 2026

#nazillon#nazillonounets#gauchistes#migrants#angleterre#brexit

@[email protected]

📢NPArevolut°R📢       Méditerranée : plus de 70 migrants portés disparus après un naufrage: Le naufrage d’une embarcation de migrants en Méditerranée centrale a fait au moins deux morts, alors que plus de 70 personnes étaient portées…  📢NPA-R #Méditerranée #Migrants #Sauvetage #DroitsDesHumains

Méditerranée : plus de 70 migr...

0 boosts · 0 favs · 0 replies · Apr 7, 2026

#mediterranee#migrants#sauvetage#droitsdeshumains

@[email protected]

Die Personenkontrollen an EU-Binnengrenzen von Innenminister Dobrindt sind vom Bayerischen Verwaltungsgerichtshof für rechtswidrig erklärt worden, da die Behauptungen der Migrantenbedrohungen nicht ausreichen.

Dobrindt ignoriert das.

Empfehlung einer Rechtsanwältin ist, dass mehr betroffene klagen müssen, damit wir den Rechtsstaat wieder herstellen können: "...sieht Rechtsanwältin Kalin Schaden..."
https://www.br.de/nachrichten/bayern/bayerische-richter-contra-dobrindt-grenzkontrollen-illegal,VGxBUYm

39 boosts · 0 favs · 18 replies · Apr 19, 2026